bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762

Preview meta tags from the bigserge.substack.com website.

Linked Hostnames

2

Thumbnail

Search Engine Appearance

Google

https://bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762

Klaus E Werner on Big Serge Thought

Dear Serge, you seem to be one of the few to extract some wisdom out of that carnage that was the battles of WW2. Far too many analyses of engagements sound like Homer's catalogue of ships - just a boring (for the not initiate reader) compilation of forces and movements. Your accounts instead are reflection and thorough analysis to actually grab the heart of the matter. But to blame for that is also the peculiar state of historiography after WW2: the victor is far too often not very much interested in actual truth, the looser glosses over his failures and seeks someone or something else to blame. The fact that the US sought the advice of - of all guys! - the german chief of staff Franz Halder to write the history of the war definitely blocked all real analysis for generations.



Bing

Klaus E Werner on Big Serge Thought

https://bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762

Dear Serge, you seem to be one of the few to extract some wisdom out of that carnage that was the battles of WW2. Far too many analyses of engagements sound like Homer's catalogue of ships - just a boring (for the not initiate reader) compilation of forces and movements. Your accounts instead are reflection and thorough analysis to actually grab the heart of the matter. But to blame for that is also the peculiar state of historiography after WW2: the victor is far too often not very much interested in actual truth, the looser glosses over his failures and seeks someone or something else to blame. The fact that the US sought the advice of - of all guys! - the german chief of staff Franz Halder to write the history of the war definitely blocked all real analysis for generations.



DuckDuckGo

https://bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762

Klaus E Werner on Big Serge Thought

Dear Serge, you seem to be one of the few to extract some wisdom out of that carnage that was the battles of WW2. Far too many analyses of engagements sound like Homer's catalogue of ships - just a boring (for the not initiate reader) compilation of forces and movements. Your accounts instead are reflection and thorough analysis to actually grab the heart of the matter. But to blame for that is also the peculiar state of historiography after WW2: the victor is far too often not very much interested in actual truth, the looser glosses over his failures and seeks someone or something else to blame. The fact that the US sought the advice of - of all guys! - the german chief of staff Franz Halder to write the history of the war definitely blocked all real analysis for generations.

  • General Meta Tags

    16
    • title
      Comments - Apex Predator: The American Army in Normandy
    • title
    • title
    • title
    • title
  • Open Graph Meta Tags

    9
    • og:url
      https://bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762
    • og:type
      article
    • og:title
      Klaus E Werner on Big Serge Thought
    • og:description
      Dear Serge, you seem to be one of the few to extract some wisdom out of that carnage that was the battles of WW2. Far too many analyses of engagements sound like Homer's catalogue of ships - just a boring (for the not initiate reader) compilation of forces and movements. Your accounts instead are reflection and thorough analysis to actually grab the heart of the matter. But to blame for that is also the peculiar state of historiography after WW2: the victor is far too often not very much interested in actual truth, the looser glosses over his failures and seeks someone or something else to blame. The fact that the US sought the advice of - of all guys! - the german chief of staff Franz Halder to write the history of the war definitely blocked all real analysis for generations.
    • og:image
      https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_680,h_680,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack.com%2Fnote%2Fc-40758762%2Fpreview.jpeg%3Fsize%3Dsm
  • Twitter Meta Tags

    8
    • twitter:label1
      Likes
    • twitter:data1
      6
    • twitter:label2
      Replies
    • twitter:data2
      0
    • twitter:title
      Klaus E Werner on Big Serge Thought
  • Link Tags

    41
    • alternate
      /feed
    • apple-touch-icon
      https://substackcdn.com/icons/substack/apple-touch-icon.png
    • canonical
      https://bigserge.substack.com/p/apex-predator-the-american-army-in/comment/40758762
    • icon
      https://substackcdn.com/icons/substack/icon.svg
    • preconnect
      https://substackcdn.com

Links

14