title

Why are We Still Being Hornswoggled? Dissolving the Hard Problem of Consciousness | Topoi

charset

UTF-8

X-UA-Compatible

IE=edge

applicable-device

pc,mobile

viewport

width=device-width, initial-scale=1

og:url

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-014-9266-3

og:type

article

og:site_name

SpringerLink

og:title

Why are We Still Being Hornswoggled? Dissolving the Hard Problem of Consciousness - Topoi

og:description

In this paper we try to diagnose one reason why the debate regarding the Hard Problem of consciousness inevitably leads to a stalemate: namely that the characterisation of consciousness assumed by the Hard Problem is unjustified and probably unjustifiable. Following Dennett (Consciousness explained. Penguin Books, New York, 1991, J Conscious Stud 3(1): 4–6, 1996, Cognition 79:221–237, 2001, J Conscious Stud 19(1):86, 2012) and Churchland (J Conscious Stud 3(5–6):402–408, 1996, Brainwise: studies in neurophilosophy. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2002), we argue that there is in fact no non-question begging argument for the claim that consciousness is a uniquely Hard Phenomenon. That is; there is no non-question begging argument for the claim that consciousness is necessarily in explicable in terms of the structure and function of mental states. Unfortunately the debate has not moved on because the majority of materialists feel the pull of the at least one of, what we call, the ‘key’ intuitions that supposedly support dualism and the existence of a Hard Phenomenon and so try to accommodate them rather than denying them. Although this a possible response to the intuitions it tends to mask the fact that there is in fact no argument for the existence of a Hard Phenomenon. So we end up participating in our own hornswoggling (Churchland in J Conscious Stud 3, (5–6):402–408, 1996) and chasing our tails trying to answer a question we should in fact ignore. We have no reason to think there is a Hard Problem of consciousness because we have no reason to think the Hard Phenomenon exists.

twitter:site

@SpringerLink

twitter:card

summary_large_image

twitter:image:alt

Content cover image

twitter:title

Why are We Still Being Hornswoggled? Dissolving the Hard Problem of Consciousness

twitter:description

Topoi - In this paper we try to diagnose one reason why the debate regarding the Hard Problem of consciousness inevitably leads to a stalemate: namely that the characterisation of consciousness...

position

1

position

2

position

3

apple-touch-icon

/oscar-static/img/favicons/darwin/apple-touch-icon-6ef0829b9c.png

canonical

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11245-014-9266-3

icon

/oscar-static/img/favicons/darwin/android-chrome-192x192.png

icon

/oscar-static/img/favicons/darwin/favicon-32x32.png

icon

/oscar-static/img/favicons/darwin/favicon-16x16.png